Ind AS 116 Lease Accounting: The 6 Implementation Errors Indian Finance Teams Keep Making

Ind AS 116 Lease Accounting: The 6 Implementation Errors Indian Finance Teams Keep Making

Follow Us:

Ind AS 116 requires lessees to recognize all eligible leases on the balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a corresponding lease liability, replacing the old operating versus finance lease distinction. Despite the standard being in effect for several years now, Indian finance teams continue to make a recurring set of errors, and most common errors are: missing embedded leases in service contracts, using the wrong discount rate, inappropriate treatment of lease modifications, election of short-term and low-value lease exemptions, incorrect treatment of variable lease payments, failing to reassess lease liabilities when terms change and incorrect recognition of initial direct costs when measuring the right-of-use asset. This article walks through each error and what causes it.

These are common mistakes and show up repeatedly in statutory audits and group reporting reviews across mid-market and large Indian companies.

Missing Embedded Leases in Service Contracts

Ind AS 116 applies to any contract that conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset for a period of time, not just contracts explicitly labeled as a lease. Service contracts for equipment, vehicles, warehousing, or IT infrastructure often contain an embedded lease that finance teams overlook because the contract is filed under procurement or IT, not facilities or leasing.

A common example is a warehousing service agreement, where the customer effectively controls a specific identified asset such as designated space, forklifts and other specified equipment throughout the contract term. In this scenario, Ind AS 116 shall be applicable and ROU and Lease liability should be recognised at the inception. If the embedded lease test is not applied to every significant contract, these arrangements stays off the balance sheet entirely, understating both assets and liabilities.

Using the Wrong Discount Rate

The lease liability is measured at the present value of lease payments that are not paid at that date, discounted using the interest rate implicit in the lease if, it can be readily determined, or the lessee’s incremental borrowing rate otherwise. Many Indian companies adopt a simplified approach by using a uniform corporate borrowing rate for every lease, regardless of the lease term, currency, or asset type, which may not fully comply with the standard.

The incremental borrowing rate should reflect what the company would have to pay to borrow, for a similar term and with similar security, the funds necessary to obtain an asset of similar value in a similar economic environment. A 10-year property lease and a 3-year equipment lease should generally not use the same discount rate, since the borrowing term and asset risk profile differ. Using one blended rate across all leases is one of the most frequently flagged issues during statutory audits of Ind AS 116 calculations.

Inappropriate treatment of lease modifications

Changes in lease terms are common such as an extension is negotiated, additional space is added, or a rent reduction is agreed upon during renegotiation. Ind AS 116 requires a specific assessment of whether a modification should be accounted for as a separate new lease or as a remeasurement of the existing lease liability, based on whether the changes increases the scope of the lease and whether the price reflects standalone pricing for that increase.

Finance teams frequently apply a blanket remeasurement approach to every modification without first testing whether the change actually meets the criteria for a separate lease. This produces an incorrect right-of-use asset and liability balance, and the error compounds over the remaining lease term since the carrying values feed into every subsequent depreciation and interest calculation.

Election of short-term and low-value lease exemptions

Ind AS 116 allows two practical exemptions: short-term leases with a lease term of 12 months or less, and leases of low-value underlying assets. These exemptions allows a lessee to recognise the lease payments as an expense on either straight-line basis over the lease term or other systematic basis. However, the exemptions have certain specific conditions that are commonly applied incorrectly.

The short-term exemption is based on the lease term at commencement, including any renewal periods the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise, not just the initial stated term. A lease with an 11-month initial term but an automatic renewal clause that the company always exercises does not qualify as short-term, even though the paperwork says 11 months. Companies that apply the exemption based purely on the document’s stated term, without assessing renewal likelihood, frequently end up understating lease liabilities.

Incorrect treatment of variable lease payments

Lease payments that vary based on an index or rate, such as payments tied to a price index, are included in the initial measurement of the lease liability using the index or rate at the commencement date. Payments that vary based on usage or performance, such as a percentage of sales for a retail lease, are excluded from the initial lease liability and recognised as expense in statement of P&L.

Finance teams often blend these two categories incorrectly, either capitalizing usage-based variable payments that should be recognised as expense or excluding index-based variable payments that should be included at commencement. This distinction matters because it directly affects the size of the right-of-use asset and liability reported on the balance sheet, and getting it wrong understates or overstates lease obligations depending on which way the error runs.

Failing to reassess lease liabilities when terms change

Beyond formal modifications, Ind AS 116 requires reassessment of the lease liability when there is a change in the assessment of whether a lessee is reasonably certain to exercise an extension or termination option, or when there is a change in index-based variable payments at the relevant reassessment date specified in the contract. This is distinct from a negotiated modification and is often missed entirely because it does not involve a new agreement being signed.

A company that initially assessed it would not exercise a lease extension option, then later changes its operational plans and decides to extend, the lease liability needs to be reassessed at that point, not wait until the original lease term is about to expire. Skipping this reassessment step means the balance sheet understates the lease liability for the period between the change in intent and the eventual remeasurement.

Incorrect recognition of initial direct costs when measuring the right-of-use asset

As per Ind AS 116, the cost of right-of-use asset shall comprise of the initial measurement of the lease liability, any lease payments made at or before the commencement date less lease incentives received, any initial direct costs incurred by the lessee, and an estimate of the costs of dismantling or restoring the underlying asset. Initial direct costs are defined narrowly as the incremental costs of obtaining a lease that would not have been incurred if the lease had not been obtained.

In India, the most common initial direct costs are stamp duty and registration charges on lease deeds and brokerage paid to property consultants, and these can be material for long-term office, warehouse, or retail leases. A common mistake made by many finance teams is to recognise these costs directly in the statement of P&L or record it as prepaid expense and amortize them over time. As per Ind AS 116, these costs must be recognised with right-of-use asset and shall be depreciated on straight line basis.

Why Do These Errors Keep Recurring Across Reporting Cycles?

Most of these errors are not one-time mistakes caught and fixed during the first year of Ind AS 116 adoption. They recur because lease accounting is treated as a static, one-time exercise rather than an ongoing process that needs to track new contracts, renegotiations, and changing business circumstances every reporting period.

Finance teams managing lease accounting through spreadsheets, rather than a dedicated lease accounting system, are particularly prone to these errors compounding over time, since each new lease or modification adds another manual calculation that needs to be tracked correctly alongside everything that came before it. This is a common gap our Accounting Advisory team identifies during technical accounting reviews, where the initial Ind AS 116 transition was done correctly, but the ongoing process for new leases and modifications was never formalized.

How Should Finance Teams Build a More Reliable Lease Accounting Process?

A few practical steps reduce the recurrence of these errors:

  • Apply the embedded lease test to every significant new contract at signing, not just contracts labeled as leases
  • Set a documented policy for determining incremental borrowing rates by lease term and asset category, rather than using one rate for everything
  • Build a checklist for every lease modification that tests scope and pricing criteria before deciding on remeasurement versus separate lease treatment
  • Reassess renewal and termination option likelihood at least annually, not only when a contract is being renegotiated
  • Revisit the internal controls around the recognition of ROU including the initial direct costs.
  • Maintain a lease register that is updated continuously, rather than reconstructed at year’s end

Companies preparing for a statutory audit or a group reporting review often find it useful to have these calculations reviewed independently before the audit cycle begins. Our Accounting Advisory team frequently reviews Ind AS 116 lease calculations as part of broader financial statement audit procedures, and catching these six errors before the audit starts is generally less disruptive than addressing them as audit findings.

How Pierag Consulting Supports Ind AS 116 Implementation

Pierag Consulting works with finance teams on Ind AS 116 lease accounting reviews, covering embedded lease identification, discount rate methodology, modification accounting, and ongoing lease register maintenance. This includes reviewing existing lease calculations for the six errors outlined above and helping finance teams build a repeatable process rather than a one-time correction. A full view of how this fits within our broader technical accounting support is available on our Accounting Advisory page.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an embedded lease under Ind AS 116?

An embedded lease exists when a contract, even one not labeled as a lease, conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset for a period of time. Service contracts for equipment, IT infrastructure, or dedicated facilities often contain embedded leases that get missed if the contract is reviewed only by procurement or operations teams.

Why does the discount rate matter so much in Ind AS 116 calculations?

The discount rate determines the present value of the lease liability and right-of-use asset. Using one blended corporate rate instead of a rate matched to each lease’s term and risk profile produces an incorrect lease liability, and this is one of the most common findings during statutory audits.

When does a lease modification require a separate new lease versus remeasurement?

A modification is treated as a separate lease only if it increases the scope of the lease, for example, by adding more space or assets, and the price reflects standalone pricing for that increase. Modifications that don’t meet both conditions are accounted for as a remeasurement of the existing lease liability.

How does the short-term lease exemption actually work?

The short-term exemption applies to leases with a term of 12 months or less, but the term must include any renewal periods the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise. A lease that looks short-term on paper but has an automatic renewal that the company always exercises does not qualify.

Why do lease accounting errors keep recurring after the initial Ind AS 116 transition?

Lease accounting is an ongoing process, not a one-time adoption exercise. New leases, modifications, and changes in renewal intentions need to be tracked every reporting period, and teams relying on manual spreadsheets without a formal review process tend to accumulate errors over successive cycles.

Recent Posts
Quality of Earnings in Indian Mid-Market Deals: The Adjustments That Move EBITDA
Quality of Earnings in Indian Mid-Market Deals: The Adjustments That Move EBITDA
Earnings, especially Earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation and Amortisation (EBITDA), are the most important factor in determining the price in...
Beyond the paperwork: what it really takes to build a GCC in India
Beyond the paperwork: what it really takes to build a GCC in India
Why people, process and technology decide whether your GCC succeeds  If you are planning a GCC in India, where is...
The Skill You Downloaded Could Be the Fraud Vector You Didn’t See Coming
The Skill You Downloaded Could Be the Fraud Vector You Didn’t See Coming
Why third-party AI skills are the next blind spot, even on enterprise AI Every few weeks, a new file does...